$B$40U8+$N$"$kJ}$O!"(Bkodama@socio.kyoto-u.ac.jp$B$^$?$O(B$B%a%$%k$rAw$k(B$B$^$G!#(B
$B!&(B$B:F3+(B$B!#(B
$B!&$B!&$3$N0l=54V!"$:$C$H8&5f<<$K$O$S$3$C$F$$$?!#$O$S$3$C$FIt20$r1x$9$N$b0-$$$N$G!"BgA]=|$r$7$?!#$@$$$VJRIU$1$?$N$G!"0JA0$h$j$O$$$d$9$/$J$C$?$H;W$&!#(B
$B!&$s$G!"8&5f<<$NL>Jm$r:n$C$?$j!"1i=,H/I=$r:G=i$K$9$k$3$H$K$J$C$?$N$G$=$N%l%8%a$rMQ0U$7$?$j!"(BUNIX$B$NJY6/$r$7$?$j!"K?65 $B!&=$O@$G$O(B$B<+A38"$r$d$C$D$1$k(B$B$3$H$K$7$?!#$^!"$3$l$K$D$$$F$ODI!9$3$3$K=q$/$3$H$G$"$m$&!#(B
$B!&:rF|!"(BM2$B$NNkLZ$5$s$,%$%.%j%9$+$i$*5"$j$K$J$i$l$?!#Ls0l%u7nH>$NN13X$r$5$l$F$$$?$N$@!#$&$i$d$^$7$$!#$s$G!"Lk$OFs?M$GK?=u65 $B%Y%s%?%`$N>l9g$O<+A3K!$d<+A38"HcH=$H$$$&7A$r$H$j!"%K!<%A%'$N>l9g$O%W%i%H%s$N%$%G%"O@$HL)@\$K7k$SIU$$$?%-%j%9%H65E*@$3&4Q!J$3$&$$$&8@$$J}$G$$$$$N$+$J!)$H$K$+$/%K!<%A%'$N$$$&!VGX8e$N@$3&!W!K$NHcH=$H$$$&7A$r$H$C$F$$$k!#(B
$B$H$$$&0c$$$O$"$k$K$;$h!"Fs?M$H$b$=$&$$$C$?@>2$E*5,HO35G0$NL7=b$d%.%^%s$rK=$-=P$7$F$$$kE@$,6&DL$7$F$$$k!#!J$"$"!"$`$D$+$7$$$3$H$r=q$/$HF,$,DK$$!D!K(B
$B!&$"$"!"=q$-$?$$$3$H$,$$$C$Q$$$"$C$?$s$@$J$"!#(B
$B!&$=$$$($P!":rF|!"(BJeremy Waldron$BJT$N(B"'Nonsense upon stilts': Bentham, Burke and Marx on the rights of man"$B$H$$$&K\$r $B$H$$$o$l$?$N$G!"!J%3%s%A%/%7%g!<65M\$J$s$F$*$l$,0l2s@8$N$H$-$K$O$b$&$J$/$J$C$F$?$@$m!"$5$C$5$H@0M}$7$m$h$J!K$H;W$$$D$D!"!V$=$&$G$9$+$=$&$G$9$+!"$"!"$=$j$c$9$P$i$7$$!"$=$l$8$c7k9=$G$9!W$H$+8@$C$F!"?^=q4[$r=P$?!#(B
$B$7$+$7!"$^$@K!3XIt$,$"$k!#%3%s%T%e!<%?8!:w$G$O!"K!3XIt$K$b$3$NK\$,$"$k$H=P$F$-$?!#$=$3$G!"@h$KE/1\$K9T$C$F!"!VAj8_MxMQ>Z!W$H$$$&$N$r=i$a$F$b$i$&!#;W$C$F$?$[$I$a$s$I$/$5$/$J$$$N$G!"%J%$%9!"$H$+$D$V$d$-$J$,$i%9%-%C%W$GK!3XIt$X!#K!3XIt$HJ83XIt$OL\$H;X$N@h$G$"$k!#(B
$B!J8*$GB)$r$7$J$,$i!K!V$"$"!"$($($H!"$<$$$<$$!"$"$N!"$3$NK\$*4j$$$7$^$9!W(B
$B!V$O$$$O$$!<$C!W!J4n!9$H$7$F=q8K$X>C$($F$$$/?^=q<<$N$*$P$5$s!K(B
$B!V!D!D!W!JBT$D$3$@$^!K(B
$B!V!D!D!W!J$^$@BT$D$3$@$^!K(B
$B!J=q8K$+$i $B!V(B$B6e7n(B$B$G$9!W(B
$B!V$[$($($C(B!?$B!W(B
$B!D$"$H$GJ9$/$H!"K!3XIt$N1!@8$O$J$s$H0lG/4VK\$r $B!&$&$&!"$M$`$M$`!#>/$7!J%Q%$%W$$$9$G!K?2$?!#$A$g$C$H5JCcE9$K9T$C$F$/$k!#(B
$B!&$"!"$=$&$=$&!"$3$l$b(B$B%Y%s%?%`!&%W%m%8%'%/%H(B$B$KLd$$9g$o$;$?$s$@$1$I!"%Y%s%?%`$N!V3F?M$O0l?M$H$7$F?t$($i$l!"2??M$b0l?M0J>e$H$7$F?t$($i$l$J$$!W$H$$$&8@L@$O!"8=:_$N$H$3$m$^$@%Y%s%?%`$NCx:nCf$K$O8+$D$+$C$F$J$$$s$@$C$F!#$b$7$+$7$?$iL$3NG'$NAp9F$K=q$$$F$"$k2DG=@-$O$"$k$i$7$$$1$I!#(B
$B8=:_!"8+$k$N$bCQ$:$+$7$$B4O@$N$^$H$a$r@=:nCf!#$"$"CQ$:$+$7$$CQ$:$+$7$$!#(B
$B!&Ck2<$,$j$+$i(Bkant$B$r=i4|2=$9$k$3$H$K7hDj!#$($($$!";_$a$F$/$l$k$J!#<:GT$7$?$i%4%a%s!#(B
$B!&(BCD-ROM$B$r$7$^$C$F$$$k$F$$$k%m%C%+!<$N80$, $B!&%P%s%I$NN}=,!#$G$-$l$P:#F|$O5"$j$?$$!J$,!D!K!#(B
$B!&$d$C$Q$j!"5"$k!#$"$"$"!"$$$m$$$m$H$d$k$3$H$,$"$k$C!#(B
$B!JK;$7$$K;$7$/$J$$$H$$$&$N$O5$;}$A$N;}$A$h$&$NLdBj$@$H;W$&$1$I!D$d$C$Q$jK;$7$$!K(B
$B!&$G$O$^$?L@F|!#$?$V$s!#(B
$B!&(Bunix$B$G$"$?$^$,%&%K%&%K$K$J$k!#$o$+$i$s!#$^$5$KKbK!$N@$3&!#$7$+$7%a%$%k$O(Bmule$B$GFI$_$?$$$N$G!"$H$K$+$/$J$s$H$+:G>.8B$N$3$H$O3P$($M$P!#(B
$B!&LkH,;~$K3X9;$KMh$k!#:rF|$NLk$+$iCk2<$,$j$^$GE%?g$7$F$$$?!#(B
$B!&Gr?e;a$,$$$i$C$7$c$k!#$J$K$+?)$Y$K9T$/$3$H$K$J$k!#$=$$$($P!"M $B!&Gr?e;a$HCY$$HU$4HS$r?)$Y$J$,$i!"G.$$?M8"O@Ah$H(B$BKhF|?7J9M>O?O@Ah(B$B!#(B
$B!J8=:_!VM>O?$N0U8+$K;?@.!W$,#1I$B!&Gr?e;a$NOC$G$O!";y6L$N2r
$B!&$7$+$7!"$d$O$j<+J,$H0c$&?M4V$d!"0-?M$@$H;W$&?M4V$r!V%R%H0J>e?M4V0J2<$NB8:_!W$H8F$V$N$O!"P~K}$K;W$($F$\$/$O9%$-$G$O$J$$!#(B
$B!&KhF|?7J9$O$\$/$b4pK\E*$K$O9%$-$G$"$k!#$7$+$7!"M>O?$K$b=pL>$r$$$l$h!"$H8@$$$?$$!#(B
$B!&!J(B$BKhF|?7J9M>O?O@Ah(B$B!"8=:_!VM>O?$N0U8+$K;?@.!W$,#1I
$B!&$&$&!"$M$`!#>/$7?2$?!#$d$O$j%Q%$%W$$$9$G!#L@F|$+$i $B!&$"$"$C!"K?65 $B!J$^!"#3!"#42s@8$r$S$S$i$;$k$K$O$A$g$&$I$$$$$+!#!K(B
$B!&(BCD-Rom$B$, $B!J(B$BKhF|?7J9M>O?O@Ah(B$B$O!"D9$$$N$GJL$N>l=j$K0\$7$?!K(B
$B!J$A$J$_$K!"$3$N7o$K4X$7$F$\$/$OE\$C$F$$$?$j$9$k$o$1$G$O$J$$$N$G!"$=$NE@$KMWCm0U!#$=$l$K$\$/$O$=$b$=$b;`7:GQ;_O@
$B!&$"$^$j$NM[5$$KM6$o$l$F!"$D$$$U$i$U$i$H5HED;3$r;6Jb$9$k$J$I$H$$$&!"(B$B$8$8$`$5$$(B$B$3$H$r$7$F!D$"!"$($0$C!"$($0!_$5$s$C!"$"$C!"$&$=$G$9$&$=$G$9$CK=$l$J$$$G$/$@$5$$$C!"$5$5$C;6Jb$O $B!J$3$@$^!V$4$C$4$a$s$J$5!"$"$C!W!K(B
$B!J%P%j%P%j%C!K(B
$B!J$3$@$^!V%.%c!$B!J%`%7%c%`%7%c%C!K(B
$B!J$3$@$^!V$C!D!D!W!K(B
$B!J!_$0$A$5$s!V!D!D%K%d%j!W!K(B
$B!J!X$3$@$^$N!J?7!K@$3&!Y40!K(B
$B!&!D:#$N$O%U%#%/%7%g%s$@$+$i?.$8$J$$$h!<$K!#$1$I!"$[$s$H$K;3$G$OO7?M$K$7$+=P2q$o$J$+$C$?!#$d$O$j?M@8$NA*Br$r$I$3$+$G8m$C$F$$$?$+!)(B
$B!&$=$N8e!"K\Ev$K$($0$A!_$s$,8=$l$?!#(BUNIX$B$N?7$?$J $B!&$($0$A$5!_$O5"$i$l$k!#$&$&!#(B
$B!&!_$0$A$5$s$J$-8e!"7l$N$K$8$`$h$&$JL5BL$JEXNO$r$7$D$D!"(Bkant$B$r85$N>uBV$KI|5"Cf!#E,Ev$K$7$F@Z$j>e$2$J$$$H5"$l$J$/$J$k!#(B
$B!&(BSCSI$BF0$+$:!#$^$5$K;~4V$N$`$@!#8}@K$7$$$,$"$-$i$a$F5"$k!#(B
($B$H$[$[!#ELJb$K$J$C$A$c$C$?$h!#(B)
$B!&!J(B$BKhF|?7J9M>O?O@Ah(B$B!"8=:_!VM>O?$N0U8+$K;?@.!W$,#1I$B!&5\:j$J$K$,$7$N9TF0$O!"@5$K!V%R%H!W$G$O$G$-$J$$!"!V?M4V!W$i$7$$9TF0$G$"$k!"$H=q$+$l$F$$$?J}$b$$$?!#$"$/$^$GH`$OF|K\$N
$B!&$^$"!"$=$l$O$=$l$H$7$F!#:rF|$O$5$s$6$s$@$C$?!#$\$/$N$h$&$J?7JF$^$8$7$c$s$,!"0-$NDk9q%^%$%/%m!_%U%H$K$?$C$?0l?M$GN)$A8~$+$&!"$J$I$H$$$&$N$,L5KE$G$"$C$?$N$@!#L5Cc$O$9$k$^$$!#%a%a%s%H!&%b%j%C(B($B!V?H$N$[$I$rCN$l!W(B)$B!#(B($B$A$,$&$C$F(B)
$B!&!J(B$BKhF|?7J9M>O?O@Ah(B$B!"8=:_!VM>O?$N0U8+$K;?@.!W$,#1I($B!V?M4V$G$J$$$N$J$iK!$G$O:[$1$J$$!W$H$$$&0U8+$r$$$?$@$$$?!#$\$/$b$=$&;W$&!#$7!_!_!_$5$s$J$s$+$O!"!V$$$d!"$3$l$O$=$&$$$&J8L.$G8@$C$H$s$N$H$A$c$&!W$H$*$C$7$c$i$l$k$o$1$G$9$,!D(B)
$B!&E/1\$GD4$Y$b$N!#$=$m$=$m;M%3%^L\$N1~MQNQM}3X$,;O$^$k!#(B
$B!&$\$/$N=P$k $B!&2PMK(B:$B2JE/1i=,(B($B1Q(B)(2)$B!">pJs$HNQM}(B(3)$B!"BhFs1i=,(B(4)
$B!&?eMK(B:$BNQM}3X9V5A(B(4)
$B!&LZMK(B:$B$J$7(B
$B!&6bMK(B:$B%V%l%s%?!<%N(B($BFH(B)(2)$B!"%7%'!<%i!<(B($BFH(B)(3)
$B!&=8Cf9V5A(B($B1J0f6Q(B)
$B!&$&$o!"$^$8$a!<$C!#5c$1$F$-$^$9!#$3$l$K2C$($FK!3XIt$N $B!&$*$/!_$/$s$,$$$k!#$*!_$@$/$s$b1~MQNQM}$N $B!&1~MQNQM}$O!"4pK\E*$K!"!V8D?M$N<+M3$r $B!&(BJeremy Waldron$B$,JT=8$7$F$F!"(B1$B$H(B6$B$,H`$NJ8>O!#$"$H$O%Y%s%?%`$d$i%^%k%/%9$d$i$N $B!&$(!_$A$5$s$,$3$i$l$F!"0NBg$J$kKb=Q$G%^%$%/%m%=!_%H$r7bGK!#$A$c$s$HF0$/$h$&$K$J$j$^$7$?!#(B
$B!&J"$b8:$C$?$7!" $B!&$H$3$m$G!#(B($B$^$@$$$?(B)
$BK!3XIt$GK\$r
$B!&!J(B$BKhF|?7J9M>O?O@Ah(B$B!"8=:_!VM>O?$N0U8+$K;?@.!W$,#1I$B!&:rF|$O5"$C$F$+$i??LkCf2a$.$^$G?2$F!"$=$l$+$i$b$=$b$=$H5/$-$F:#F|$N#2%3%^L\$K$"$k2JE/$NM==,$r$7$?!#$9$k$H$D$$$K$&$A$N%^%$%/!_%=%U%H$^$GH?Mp$r5/$3$7$?$N$G!"(Bms-ime97$B$rA0$N$d$D$HF~$l49$($?!#(B
$B!&$=$s$J$3$H$r$7$F$$$k$&$A$KD+$K$J$C$F$7$^$C$?$N$G!"$$$D$b$h$j#1;~4V$[$IAa$/2H$r=P$k$H!"8+;v$KDL6P%i%C%7%e$K$V$D$+$C$F;`$L;W$$$r$7$?!#EE $B!&:#F|$O$$$m$$$mH/I=$d$i!"(B($B1i=,$N;O$^$j$J$N$GNQM}8&5f<<$N?M$,$_$s$J=8$^$C$F(B)$B<+8J>R2p$d$i$"$k$N$GBgJQ$G$"$k!#(B
$B!V$(!A!"5~ETBg3X$N$3$@$^$G$9!#%Y%s%?%`$J$I$H$$$&%^%$%J!<$J;WA[2H$rJY6/$7$?$j$7$F$$$^$9!#$(!A!"$"$^$j3X9;$KMh$J$$$N$G$_$J$5$s$,$\$/$r8&5f<<$G8+$k$3$H$O$a$C$?$K$J$$$H;W$o$l$^$9$,!"$^$"!"2x$7$$$b$N$G$O$J$$$N$G!"8+$+$1$?$H$-$O$;$$$<$$$3$-;H$C$F$d$C$F$/$@$5$$!D!W(B
$B!&$$$+$s$$$+$s!"$3$s$J;v$r$7$F$$$k>l9g$8$c$J$$!#(B
$B!&$"$"$"!"$D$+$l$?$C!#$M!"?2$?$$!#$$$m$$$m$"$C$?$,!"8e$G=q$/!#(B
$B!&Fs%3%^L\$N $B!&;M%3%^L\$O!"$*BT$A$+$M$NNQM}3XBhFs1i=,!#65 $B!&4pACNQM}3XFI=q2q!J$=$N$&$A>\:Y$r$3$3$K:\$;$k$D$b$j!K$NM6$$$O7k9=H?1~$,$"$C$?$N$G4n$V!#$^$?!"(BM2$B$N$9!_$-$5$s$H$O:#=5Kv$+$i%Y%s%?%`$N!X=x@b!Y$rFI$`$3$H$K7h$^$C$?!#6bMKLk6e;~$+$i$d$k$N$G!"!VLkCf$N%Y%s%?%`FI=q2q!W$HL>IU$1$k$3$H$K$9$k!#$(,5$A$5$s$N;22C$,K>$^$l$k!#(B
$B!&$=$N8e8&5f<<$NL>Jm:n$j$KNe$_!"=*$o$C$F$+$iK?=u65,6<<$K9T$/$H!"K?,765 $B!JHh$l$F$$$k$H$3$&$$$&J8>O$K$J$j$^$9!K(B
$B!&!J(B$BKhF|?7J9M>O?O@Ah(B$B!"8=:_!VM>O?$N0U8+$K;?@.!W$,#1I($B8=:_!"NY$j$G%3%s%T%e!<%?$H>-4}$r;X$5$l$F$$$kJ}$,Ls0lL>(B)
$B!&
$B!X$d$"$d$"!"!VK?;a!W$N4z?'$,$I$&$b0-$=$&$@$J$!!#(B
$B$7$+$78=:_!V@55A!W$NB&$K$"$k$"$s$?$NO@D4$O!"(B
$B>/!90BD>$G$O$J$$$+!)(B
$B!VM>O?!W;a$,?M$r!V?M4V$G$O$J$$!W$H$$$&$N$O5v$;$J$$$H$7$F!"(B
$B$G$O<+J,$NL<$,;&$5$l$??F$,!V$"$s$JE[$O?M4V$8$c$J$$!*!W$H(B
$B6+$V$N$O$I$&H=CG$9$k$N$+!)!Y(B
$B!&A0H>ItJ,$O3N$+$K$=$&$@$H;W$&!#$\$/$O$$$D$N$^$K$+@$O@(B(?)$B$K8e$m=b$5$l$F!">/!9L5HcH=$J0U8+$r8@$C$F$$$?$N$+$bCN$l$J$$!#(B
$B!&$5$i$K=q$-$?$$$3$H$O$"$k$,!"Hh$l$F$k$+$i$^$?=q$/!#(B
$B!&$3$l$+$i7r9/?GCG!#$7$+$7!"$*$/$@!_$s$K$b;XE&$5$l$?$h$&$K!"(B
$BIT7r9/?GCG$H$$$$$+$($F$b:9$7;Y$($J$+$m$&!"(B
$BA0F|$K%Q%$%W$$$9$G?2$F$$$k$\$/$N>l9g$O!#(B
($B$^$"!"$=$b$=$b!VIT7r9/?GCG!W$H$$$&L>A0$NJ}$,!"(B
$B$_$s$J$o$/$o$/$7$F?G$F$b$i$$$K9T$/$h$&$J5$$,$9$k$,!D!#(B
$B!V$O$$!"$"$J$?$OIT7r9/EY(B3$B$G$9$C!W$H$+8@$o$l$?$i3Z$7$$$H;W$&(B)
$B!&!J(B$BKhF|?7J9M>O?O@Ah(B$B!"(B
$B8=:_!VM>O?$N0U8+$K;?@.!W$,(B1$BI3$BI<(B$B!K(B
($B!V$d$a$J$5$$!W$rA*$s$@?M$O!"$J$k$Y$/0U8+$r$*=q$-$/$@$5$$!#(B
$B2?$b=q$$$F$$$J$$$H0[>o$K62$$$N$G!#(B'Quit it.'$B$@$1$,Mh$k$H!"$[$s$H$K62$$(B)
$B!&!J(B$BKhF|?7J9M>O?O@Ah(B$B!"(B
$B8=:_!VM>O?$N0U8+$K;?@.!W$,(B1$BI4$BI<(B$B!K(B
($B?t$,$@$s$@$s2x$7$/$J$C$F$-$^$7$?(B)
$B!&86J8$r ($B<:8@!&K=O@$N@d$($J$$$\$/$,8@$&$N$b$^$k$G@bF@NO$,$J$$$N$G$9$,!#(B
$B$$$d!"$`$7$m$=$l$@$+$i$3$=$"$k$N$+(B?)
$B$H$$$&$+!"$\$/$,5\:j$J$K$,$7$NFy?F$@$C$?$i!"E\$k$@$m$&!"(B
$B$H$$$&46$8$G$9!#$$$d!"$[$s$H$K$=$&$@$C$?$i$8$C$H2fK}$9$k$+$J(B?
$B!&%Z%k!<$N;v7o2r7h$K6C$/!#%F%m%j%9%H(B14$B?MA40w $B!&8a8e$+$i$O#2;~4V$[$I!"BhFs1i=,$NH/I=$NM=9T$r$h$7!_$i$5$s$H!_$/$@$/$s$K ($B$*$/!_$/$s!">! $B!&$=$m$=$m5"$k!#;P$,$&$A$K5"$C$F$-$F$$$k$N$G!"L@F|$OMh$l$J$$$+$b$7$l$J$$!#(B
($B;E;v$O$?$^$k$h!"$I$3$^$G$b(B)
$B!&:G6a<+J,$N=q$$$?F|5-$rFI$s$GFC$K46$8$k$N$O!"?M$HOC$7$J$,$i=q$$$?$b$N$O$`$A$c$/$A$c$G$"$k$3$H!#@UG$$,;}$F$kJ8>O$r=q$/$?$a$K$O!"0l?M$G$$$k$H$-$K=q$/$+!"?M$,$$$F$b%X%C%I%U%)%s$G2;3Z$rD0$-$J$,$i=q$+$J$$$H$J$i$M$P$J$i$J$$!"$H;W$C$?!#(B
$B!&$"$H!"E0LkL@$1$N;W9MG=NO$N8:B`$7$F$$$k$H$-$K=q$$$F$$$kJ8>O$b!"$1$C$3$&$9$4$$!#(B
$B!&$^$?!"47$l$J$$(BUNIX$B>e$GF|5-$r99?7$7$F$$$k$N$b$D$i$+$C$?$j$9$k!#Aa$/>eC#$;$M$P!#(B
$B!&LZMK$O=P$kM=Dj$N $B!&JY6/JY6/!#$A$g$C$H$4$O$s?)$Y$K9T$-$^$9$+!#(B
$B!&$+$o$0$A$+$$$8$N!X?4!Y$,=*$o$C$F$7$^$C$?!#$J$+$J$+!XD@L[$N4OBb!Y$OD6$($i$l$^$;$s$J$"!#(B
$B!&$5!"2?$b$9$k$3$H$b$J$7!"5"$j$^$9$+!#L@F|$O $B!&:rLk$O5W$7$V$j$K?7J9$N@Z$jH4$-$r$7$F$$$?!#$^$@5nG/$N(B11$B7n$N?7J9$@$,!#$=$N$;$$$G:#D+$O?2K7!#(B
$B!&$3$l$+$i#2%3%^L\$N $B!&L2$$!#$5$C$-!"@86($N=q@RIt$G(B3$B7nKv$KCmJ8$7$?%V%l%s%?!<%N$NK\$,Ce$$$?$+$rJ9$-$K8@$C$?$i!"!V3$30H/Cm$7$^$7$?$+$i$"$H(B2$B!"(B3$B%+7n$+$+$j$^$9!W$@$C$F!#A*Br$r8m$l$j!#(B
$B!&;P$,$\$/$NK\C*$K$"$k_'_7N6I'$N!X9uKb=Q$N
$B!& $B!&%Y%s%?%`FI=q2q=*$o$j!#%Y%s%?%`$NJ8>O$,$+$J$jFq$7$$$N$G!"$_$J$GRq6c$7$J$,$i?J$`!#(B
$B!&Hh$l$?!#D9$$0lF|!#(B
$B!&L2$$$,!"$^$@855$$J$N$G$I$s$I$s=q$/!#(B
$B!&F|K\$N%Y%s%?%`%U%!%s$KAw$kBg%K%e!<%9!#$4B8CN$N$h$&$K$o$l$o$l$K$O!"(B'Bentham'$B$r!V%Y%s%?%`!W$HFI$`$+!"$O$?$^$?!V%Y%s%5%`!W$HFI$`$+!"$H$$$&BgLdBj$,$rJz$($F$$$k$o$1$@$,!":rF|$^$?@-D($j$b$J$/%f%K%t%!!<%7%F%#!&%+%l%C%8!&%*%t!&%m%s%I%s$K$"$k!"%Y%s%?%`%W%m%8%'%/%H$N%[!<%`%Z!<%8$N@=:n $B!&$H$$$&$o$1$G!"$H$j$"$($:%O%j%9;a$N8@MU$r?.$8$F!"$3$NLdBj$O0l7oMnCe!#$(!"$3$l$+$i$\$/$,$I$&H/2;$9$k$+$C$F!)$=$l$O$G$9$M$(!"K?!_65 $B!&:G6aGc$$J*$r$9$k$H!"%l%8$GI,$:!V!A1_(B$B$h$j(B$B$*MB$+$j$7$^$9!W$"$k$$$O!V!A1_(B$B$+$i(B$B$*MB$+$j$7$^$9!W$H$$$&I=8=$r<*$K$9$k$N$@$,!"$3$l$O$:$C$H@N$+$i$9$k8@$$J}$J$N$@$m$&$+!)$J$>!#(B
$B!&0lBNA4BN!"!V!A1_$h$j!W$N!V$h$j!W$H$+!V$+$i!W$O$I$&$$$&0UL#$J$N$@$m$&$+!)$J$<%l%8$N$*$P$A$c$s$d$*;P$5$s$d%(%H%;%H%i$O!"!V!A1_$*MB$+$j$7$^$9!W$H$O8@$o$J$$$N$@$m$&$+!#$`$`$`!"$^$9$^$9$J$>!#(B
$B!&!V!A1_$h$j(B($BBe6b!A1_$r(B)$B$$$?$@$-$^$9(B$B!W$J$i$P0UL#$ODL$8$k$N$@$,!"$I$&9M$($F$b!V!A1_$h$j$*MB$+$j$7$^$9!W$O0UL#$r@.$5$J$$!#%l%8$N?M$O@i1_;%$d0lK|1_;%(B$B$r(B$BMB$+$k$o$1$G$"$C$F!"@i1_;%$d0lK|1_;%(B$B$+$i(B$BMB$+$k$o$1$G$O$J$+$m$&!#(B
$B!&$O$C!#$^!"$^$5$+$+$l$i$O5R$N$3$H$r$*6b$HF10l;k$7$F$$$k$N$G$O$C!)$D$^$jKM$,0lK|1_=P$7$?$H$9$k$H(B($B$a$C$?$K$J$$$,(B)$B!"H`$i$O!V0lK|1_$+$i$*MB$+$j$7$^$9!W$H8@$&$o$1$@$,!"$B!&$&$&$`!"%l%8$N?M$?$A$*$=$k$Y$7!#(B
($B$"$NF|K\8l$O$I$3$+$*$+$7$$$H;W$$$^$;$s$+!)(B)
$B!&$"$"$M$`!#1Q8l$NK\$rFI$_;O$a$?$i$9$0$K?2$F$7$^$C$?!#5/$-$k$H!"D+$O$^$@4($$$N$G!"%,%9%9%H!<%V$r$D$1$k!#$3$N%9%H!<%V$O%,%9$N85@r$r3+$1$?$^$^$K$7$F$*$/$H!"(B($B$I$3$G$b$l$F$$$k$N$+$O$J$>$@$,(B)$BIt20$NCf$,%,%9=-$/$J$k$H$$$&$*$=$m$7$$BeJ*$@$+$i!"$&$+$&$+$D$1$C$Q$J$7$G$O?2$i$l$J$$!#(B
$B!&$5$F!"JY6/JY6/!#(B
$B!&!V(B$B!A1_$h$j$*MB$+$j$7$^$9(B$B!W$H$$$&8@$$J}$K$D$$$F$O!"$9$G$K%M%C%H>e$G8l$C$F$$$k?M$,$$$k!"$H$$$&$3$H$r65$($F$b$i$C$?!#L5CG$G(BURL$B$r$*CN$i$;$9$k$,!"(B"http://www.asahi-net.or.jp/~lf4a-okjm/9609.htm#18"$B$r;2>H$5$l$?$7!#(B
$B!&<+A3K!$K$D$$$FJY6/Cf!#%8%g%s!&%m%C%/$N!XE}<#FsO@!Y$O$=$N$&$AFI$^$J$$$H$J$"!#(B
$B!&$h$7$`!_$5$s$,$$$i$C$7$c$k!#$3!_$^$O$*$J$+$,8:$C$?$N$G5JCcE9$X!#(B
$B!&$^$8$a$K1Q8l$J$I$rFI$`!#$3$l$+$i;P$J$I$HBT$A9g$o$;!#$=$N8e$O%P%s%I$J$I$NN}=,!#(B
$B!c$_$J$5$s!"E75$$,NI$$$N$G30$K=P$F%i%8%*BNA`$r$7$^$7$g$&!d(B
$B!&D92,E7K~5\$J$I$K9T$/!#$D$D$8$,??$C@V$@$C$?$j$9$k!#?M$,B?$+$C$?$j$b$9$k!#(B
$B!&@hF|!"?7J9$N@Z$jH4$-$r>/$7$7$?$o$1$@$,!"(B$B1g=u8r:](B$B$K4X$9$kFI $B!V8EBe=w@-$O@8L?$r@8$_=P$9$b$N$H$7$F?r$a$i$l$?$H$$$&!#$7$+$7CKCf?4$N $B!&1g=u8r:]$NOC$r$9$k$N$K$3$l0J>e$U$5$o$7$$!"M:Bg$JF3F~$O9M$($i$l$^$$!#$3$N?M$NL>;z$O!"$R$g$C$H$9$k$H!VJ?DM!W$H$$$&$N$G$O$J$+$m$&$+!#(B
$B!V$=$l$r$J$s$H$+$7$J$1$l$P$H9M$($O$8$a$??M!9$ND9$$4V$N1?F0$HEXNO$K$h$C$F!"$h$&$d$/F@$i$l$??M4V$H$7$F$N8"Mx!"==J,$G$O$J$$$K$7$F$b!"=w@-$N4pK\E*$J?M8"$,G'$a$i$l$D$D$"$k!#$=$s$J;~!"$=$l$r<+$iJ|4~$9$k$N$,Gd=U!a1g=u8r:]$@!#!W(B
$B!&FI$s$G$F!V$O!"$O$l$k$d$C(I#$B$H6+$S=P$7$?$/$J$k$[$I!"9k2w$JE83+$G$"$k!#!VGd=U$r$9$k!a4pK\E*?M8"$rJ|4~$9$k!W$H$$$&%F!<%<$,$3$3$K$*$$$FL@3N$KBG$A=P$5$l$k!#H`$K$h$l$P!"Gd=U!&1g=u8r:]$r$9$k$3$H$O!"$9$J$o$AE[Nl$K$J$k$3$H$J$N$G$"$k!#(B
$B!V!HGd=U$7$F2?$,0-$$!I!H8D?M$N<+M3$@!I$H5oD>$j!"$&$=$V$/?M!9$K$O2?$b$$$&$3$H$O$J$$!#$7$+$79%4q?4$G$d$C$F$_$h$&$+$H9M$($F$$$k?M$d!":#!"8e2y$7$F$$$k?M!"$A$g$C$HN)$A;_$^$C$F9M$($F$_$h$&!#!W(B
$B!&!VGd=U$r$7$F4pK\E*?M8"$r $B!V?M@8$rEj$2=P$5$J$$$G!#?M@8$3$s$J$b$s$@$h$H;W$C$F$7$^$o$J$$$G!#$"$J$?$N?M@8$O$b$C$H?<$/!"H~$7$/$+$1$,$($N$J$$Bg@Z$J$b$N$N$O$:$@!#$=$l$rA*$V$N$O$"$J$?<+?H$@!#!W(B
$B!&7k$S$K$*$$$F!"46>p$KAJ$($kH~$7$$J8>O$,K~3+$N:y$N$h$&$KMp$l:i$$$F$$$k!#$3$3$G$^$?@h$[$I$N!VGd=U$r$9$k!a4pK\E*?M8"$rJ|4~$9$k!W$H$$$&%F!<%<$,7A$rJQ$($F7+$jJV$5$l$k!#$9$J$o$A!"!VGd=U$r$9$k!a?M@8$rEj$2=P$9!W$H$$$&7A$G!#(B
$B!&$3$l$rFI$s$@=w@-$ON^$7$F2y$$2~$a$:$K$O$$$i$l$J$$$G$"$m$&!#$=$l$@$1$G$O$J$$!#$3$NJ8>O$OCK@-$N$\$/$K$^$GH?>J$r6/$$$k$N$G$"$k!#$J$<$J$i!"$3$NJ8>O$K8=$l$k%F!<%<$G$"$k!VGd=U$r$9$k!a?M@8$rEj$2=P$9!W$,!"$\$/$K$H$C$F$O!V(B$BE/3X(B$B$r$9$k!a?M@8$rEj$2=P$9!W$N$h$&$KFI$a$F$7$^$&$+$i$G$"$k!#(B
$B!V!HE/3X$7$F2?$,0-$$!I!H8D?M$N<+M3$@!I$H5oD>$j!"$&$=$V$/?M!9$K$O2?$b$$$&$3$H$O$J$$!#$7$+$79%4q?4$G$d$C$F$_$h$&$+$H9M$($F$$$k?M$d!":#!"8e2y$7$F$$$k?M!"$A$g$C$HN)$A;_$^$C$F9M$($F$_$h$&!#!W(B
$B!V?M@8$rEj$2=P$5$J$$$G!#?M@8$3$s$J$b$s$@$h$H;W$C$F$7$^$o$J$$$G!#$"$J$?$N?M@8$O$b$C$H?<$/!"H~$7$/$+$1$,$($N$J$$Bg@Z$J$b$N$N$O$:$@!#$=$l$rA*$V$N$O$"$J$?<+?H$@!#!W(B
$B!&$$$d$O$d!"4uBe$NL>J8$G$"$k!#(B
$B!&5"$j$^$9!#L@F|$OMh$^$;$s!#(B
$B!&CY9oCY9o!##4%3%^L\$,;O$^$C$F$^$9$C$F$P!#(B
$B!&F|MKF|$O?2E]$7$?!#$7$+$b7nMKF|$O?2K7!#$I$&$J$C$F$k$s$@!"$\$/$NBN$O!)(B
$B!&$*Ck$,$^$@$@$C$?$N$G!"!X%.%c%i%j!<%U%'%$%/!Y$rFI$_$K!"9T$-IU$1$NDj?)20$X!#$&!<$s!"FI$^$;$k$J$"!":YLnITFsI'$O!#(B
$B!&1+$,9_$kCf$rJb$$$F5"$C$F$/$k!#:#F|$O<>EY$,>/$79b$$$,!"$J$+$J$+J70O5$$,$"$k!#$3$&$$$&1+$O7y$$$G$O$J$$!#(B
$B!&>/$7?2$k(B($B%$%9$G(B)$B!#$J$+$J$+JY6/$9$k5$$K$J$i$J$$!#%8%g%s!&%m%C%/$N!X;TL1@/I\O@!Y$rFI$s$G!"$J$<$3$NK\$,8EE5$H$5$l$F$$$k$N$+IT;W5D$K;W$&!#Nr;KE*2ACM$7$+$J$$K\$G$"$k!#$^$k$GE7F0@b$K$D$$$F$NK\$rFI$s$G$$$k$h$&$J5$$K$5$;$i$l$k!#(B($B$J$I$H$D$$$D$$0N$=$&$J$3$H$r8@$C$F$_$?$$G/:"$J$N$G$9!#5v$7$F(B)
$B!&7nMK#4%3%^$N1~MQNQM}3X$G$O!";`7:GQ;_O@$r$d$k$D$b$j$J$N$G!"$3$l$b$=$N$&$AA0$N;qNA$J$I$r@0M}$7$F=`Hw$;$M$P$J$k$^$$!#:G6aK?Kc86$dK?5\:j$H$$$&!VD60-
$B!&JY6/$7$?$/$J$$$N$G!"%j%s%/$r$?$I$C$F;0@iN$!"9qO"$N%Z!<%8$dB>?M$NF|5-$J$I$r1\Mw$9$k!#CN$i$J$$?M$NF|5-$,@1$N?t$[$I$?$/$5$s$"$k$N$G05E]$5$l$k!#$O$C$-$j8@$C$F2?$+6u62$m$7$$$b$N$r46$8$?!#(B
$B!V$3$s$J$K$?$/$5$s$N?M$,KhF|KhF|KhF|KhF|%M%C%H>e$KF|5-$r=q$$$F$k$s$@(B($B$=$7$F$\$/$b$=$N0l?M$G$"$j!"$=$N0l?M$G$7$+$J$$$N$@(B...)$B!W(B
...$BK:$l$h$&!"8+$J$+$C$?$3$H$K$7$h$&!#(B
$B!&$^$?!X%.%c%i%j!<%U%'%$%/!Y$rFI$_$K$4HS$r?)$Y$K9T$3$&$+$J!#(B
$B!&$.$g$($C!#$b$b$b$&$3$s$J;~4V$C!#%^%s%,$rFI$s$G?M@8$rK@$K?6$k!"$^$?3Z$7$+$i$:$d!#(B
$B!&$M!"$M$`$$!D!#(B
$B!&$"$"!"NI$/?2$?(B($B%$%9$G(B)$B!#(B
$B!&$5$`$$$5$`$$!#$D$$$KIw $B!&5JCcE9$G!X$O$8$a$N0lJb!Y$NBh0l4,$rFI$`!#$3$l$^$G5$$E$+$J$+$C$?$,!"$3$N?M$b>.NS$^$3$H(B("What's Michael"$B$J$I(B)$B$N%"%7%9%?%s%H$r$d$C$F$$$?$N$+$J!"$H;W$&!#$-$&$A$+$:$R$m(B("Be-Bop High School")$B$N3($K$b;w$F$$$k5$$,$9$k!#$b$7$+$9$k$H$3$NFs?M$K$b4X78$,$"$k$N$+$J!)(B
($B$&!<$`!"%^%s%,2H?ML.?^$,M_$7$$$J(B...)
$B!&8a8e$+$i$9$:!_;a$K $B!&$&!<$`!"<+A3K!<+A38"$V$D$V$D$V$D(B...$B!#(B
$B!&$5$C$-8&5f<<$K0lI$%_%D%P%A$,F~$C$F$-$?!#%V%s%V%s8@$$$J$,$iAk$K$V$D$+$C$F$&$k$5$$$7!"0%$l$G$b$"$k$N$G!"Ak$r3+$1$F$d$C$?!#$7$+$7!"2 $B!&8&5f<<$KLa$C$F$b$&0lEYAk$+$i2<$r$N$>$-9~$`$H!"8=:_J83XItEl4[$O9);vCf$G!"JI$K9);vMQ$NB->l$,AH$^$l$F$$$k$N$@$,!" $B!&$H$$$&$o$1$G!"$J$>$O$9$Y$F2r$1$?$C$F$s$G!":#$+$i $B!&Bg>fIW$G$7$?!#Bg>fIW$G$7$?!#(B
$B!&L\N)$?$J$$$h$&$K!"$=$=$/$5$3$=$3$=$C$HB->l$KEP$j!"$5$5$5$5$C$HG&
$B!&!_$:$-$5$s$O$I$&$d$iL@F|$@$H;W$C$F$$$?$i$7$/!"#2;~$+$i;O$a$k$3$H$K$J$C$?!#(B
$B!&$9!_$-$5$s$H$NM=9T1i=,=*$o$j!#$"$s$^$j$&$^$/9T$+$J$+$C$?$N$G!"IT0B$K$J$C$F$-$?!#$&$&$&!#OC$NFbMF$OLLGr$$$H;W$&$s$@$1$I(B...
$B!&$4$O$s$r?)$Y$F5"$j$^$9!#L@F|$b3X9;$KMh$^$9!# $B!&$9$:!_$5$s$H$4$O$s$r?)$Y$F!"$D$$La$C$F$-$F$7$^$$$^$7$?!#$G$O!":#EY$3$=K\Ev$K5"$j$^$9!#L2$$!#(B
$B!&:rF|$b5"$C$?$iD+$^$G?2E]$7$?!#2H$O?2$k$?$a$KB8:_$9$k!#(B
$B!&<+E> $B!&M9JX6I$K9T$C$FCkHS$r?)$Y$h$&!#$=$&$7$h$&!#(B
$B!&=54)%^%,%8%s$N!X(BDESPERADE$B!Y$,=*$o$C$F$7$^$C$?!#:G6a$N%P%s%IL!2h$C$FD9B3$-$7$J$$$N$,B?$$$J$"!#LLGr$$$N$K(B...
$B!&M
$B!&$^$@??LkCf!&(B
$B!&$b$&D+!&(B
$B!&CkA0!&(B
$B!&Ck2a$.!&(B
$B!&Ck2<$,$j!&(B
$B!&M
$B!&Lk!&(B
04/19/97($BEZ(B)
$B!&Lk!&(B
$B!&??LkCf!J$=$m$=$m
04/20/97($BF|(B)
$B!&??LkCf!&(B
$B!&LkL@$1$O$^$@$=$&!&(B
$B!&D+!&(B
$B!&$^$@D+!&(B
$B!&Ck!&(B
$B!&Ck2<$,$j!&(B
$B!&Lk!&(B
$B!&$5$i$KLk!&(B
04/21/97($B7n(B)
$B!&Ck!&(B
$B!&Ck$9$.!&(B
$B!&M
Contents
04/22/97($B2P(B)
$B!&D+!&(B
$B!&Lk!&(B
$B!&??LkCf!&(B
04/23/97($B?e(B)
$B!&??LkCf!&(B
$B!&D+!&(B
$B!&Lk!&(B
04/24/97($BLZ(B)
$B!&M
$B!&Lk!&(B
$B!&$5$i$KLk!&(B
04/25/97(Fri)
$B!&D+!&(B
$B!&Ck!&(B
$B!&M
$B!&LkCf!&(B
04/26/97(Sat)
$B!&??LkCf!&(B
$B!V(B$B!A1_$h$j$*MB$+$j$7$^$9(B$B!W(B$B$K$D$$$F(B($BDI5-(B)
$B!&AaD+!&(B
$B!&D+!&(B
$B!&Ck2a$.!&(B
$B!&M
$B!&LkCf!&(B
04/28/97(Mon)
$B!&Ck2<$,$j!&(B
$B!&M
$B!&Lk!&(B
$B!&??LkCf!&(B
04/29/97(Tues)
$B!&??LkCf2<$,$j!&(B
$B!&D+!&(B
$B!&$^$@D+!&(B
$B!&$*Ck!&(B
$B?HEj$2$9$k%K!<%A%'(B
$B!&M
04/30/97(Wed)
$B!&Ck2<$,$j!&(B
$B!&M
$B!&LkCf!&(B
Satoshi Kodama
kodama@ethics.bun.kyoto-u.ac.jp
All rights unreserved.
Last modified: Thu Jan 21 02:37:29 JST 1999