$B!VKhF|%P%?!<$P$+$j?)$Y$F$$$l$P!"3'$5$s$O%a%?%\%j%C%/>I8u72$K$J$k!#(B $B?M8"$@$1$r?)$Y2a$.$l$P!"F|K\
I8u72$K$J$k$s$G$9$M!W(B ---$B0K?aJ8It2J3XAj!"D9:j8)$G$N<+L1E^;YItBg2q$K$F(B
$B5/$-$k!#Lk$KIwO$$KF~$C$?J}$,$h$/L2$i$l$k5$$,$9$k!#(B $B:G6a9S$l5$L#$NH)$ND4;R$b$h$$!#(B
$B$"$l!"!V$h$/L2$i$l$k!W$H$$$&I=8=$OJQ$+$J(B? $B!VL2$l$k!W(B? $B$H;W$C$?$i!"(B $BK?:J$K!VL2$i$l$LLk$N$?$a$K!W$H$$$&I=8=$,$"$k$+$iBg>fIW$H;XE&$5$l$?!#(B
$BD+!"K?%9%?%P$K9T$-!"K?O@J8$r5^$$$GFI$`!#(B
$B$*Ck!"K?%i%s%A%g%s!&%;%_%J! $B$*Ck$9$.$+$i=$O@$N?3::2q$K;22C!#::FI0l7o!#$J$s$H$+L5;v$K=*$($k!#(B
$B$=$l$+$i!"K?=$O@@8$NH/I=869F$N
$B$=$&$$$($P!":rF|%]%C%2$+$i!V!X;WA[!Y$NK]Lu$rAa$/Aw$C$F$/$l!W(B
$B$H%a!<%k$,Mh$?$N$G!":#F|Aw$C$F$*$$$?!#(B
$BC/$+$,D+F|?7J9$N5-;v$N$3$H$rCN$i$;$?$K0c$$$J$$!#(B
$B$&!A$s!"$h$/?2$?$,(B($B0-$$L4$b8+$?(B)$B!"$b$&$[$\Iw
$BDj;~=P6P$7$F!"8aA0Cf$KK?K]Lu$N2r@b$r40@.$5$;$k!#(B
$BCk?)$r$H$C$?$"$H!"K?=$O@@8$NH/I=$NM=9T1i=,$r$b$&0lEYJ9$/!#(B
$B$=$l$+$iK??3::2q$N8a8e$N%;%C%7%g%s$K;22C$7!"(B
$B1o$N2<$N%^%$%/;}$A$H$7$F(B3$B;~4VH>$[$IF/$/!#;`$L!#(B
$B$=$N4V$KK?=$O@@8$bH/I=!#
$BLk!"(B($BJL$N(B)$BK?=$O@@8$N8&5f7W2h0F$rJ9$$$?$"$H!"(B
$BK?;a$i$HK\6?$G0{$`!#BND4$O:#0l$D$@$C$?$,!"(B
$B>FCq$r$h$/0{$s$G$7$^$&!#(B
$BK?:J$,ESCf$G9gN.$9$k!#4?CL!#(B
$B:,DE$K9T$-!"$b$&0lGU0{$s$@$"$H!"(B
$B??LkCf$K%?%/%7!<$G5"Bp!#(B
$BD+$K@8%4%_$r=P$7$?$"$H!"$*Ck6a$/$^$G$h$/?2$k!#(B
$B$*$+$2$GBND4$O0l1~2sI|$7$?$h$&$@!#:#Lk$b$h$/?2$k$h$&$K$7$h$&!#(B
$B2H$G$*Ck$r?)$Y$F$$$?$i!"K?Jl?F$+$iEEOC!#(B
$B8|O+Aj$N!V;:$`5!3#!WH/8@$,5$$K$J$C$F$$$?$h$&$G!"(B
$B%[!<%`%Z!<%8$KJQ$J$3$H$r=q$+$J$$$h$&$K5$$r$D$1$J$5$$$H8@$o$l$k!#(B
$B$;$$$<$$5$$r$D$1$k$3$H$K$7$h$&!#(B
$B$*Ck$O$d$-$=$P!#Ck2<$,$j!"E75$$,NI$+$C$?$N$GK?:J$HK\6p9~$^$GJb$-!"(B
$BJ70O5$$NNI$$5JCcE9$G$7$P$i$/K]Lu$N;E;v!#(B
$BK?:J$OJ,@OE*%^%k%/%9
$BM
$B%a%b!#:#8e(B10$BG/$OK]Lu$r$7$J$$$3$H!#(B
$BK]Lu$7$F$$$k;~4V$,$"$C$?$iK\$r=q$1!#(B
$B%a%b!#(Bprofessional$B$@$1$G$J$/(Btechnical$B$b$H$-$I$-!V@lLgE*!W$HLu$5$l$k!#(B
$B5;=QE*$J$b$N$O@lLgE*$G$"$k!"$H$+!#(B
$B??LkCf$^$GK]Lu$r$7!"$"$H0lB)$H$$$&$H$3$m$G="?2$N;~4V$K$J$C$?$N$GIwO$$KF~$k!#(B
$B$"$H$O8+D>$7$r$7$FF|K\8l$NJ88%0FFb$@$J!#(B
$BM
$BM=Ls$r$7$F$$$?EE
$B$a$G$?$$%a!<%k0l7o!#K?;a$,3X?6(BDC2$B$K:NMQ$5$l$?$=$&$@!#(B
$BFsEY?2!#(B
$B:#F|$OK?:J$,MQ;v$G=P3]$1$F$$$k$N$G!"$*Ck$O<+J,$G:n$k!#$&$I$s!#(B
$B?7J9!#L@F|$N=`Hw$r$7$J$1$l$P!#(B
$BCk2<$,$j$KCO2
$B5/$-$k!#9,$$Iw
$B8aA0Cf$OK?%9%?%P$G?7J9$rFI$s$G$+$i=P6P!#(B
$BHs>o6P$N=`Hw$r:Q$^$;!"K?;a$HCk?)$r?)$Y$F$+$iHSED66$X!#(B
$BK?Hs>o6P$O(B3$BG/@8Aj
$BCk2<$,$j$+$iM
$B$J$s$H$+5/$-$k!#(B
$B%a%b!#$=$&$$$($P!"@hF|!"%N%i!&%8%g!<%s%:$N;0KgL\$N%"%k%P%`$r9XF~$7$?!#(B
$B$b$&>/$7A0$K$O!"(BThe Feeling$B$H$$$&%P%s%I$N0lKgL\$N%"%k%P%`$b9XF~$7$?!#(B
$B8aA0Cf$OK?1Q8lJ88%9VFI!#$*Ck$OK?%i%s%A%g%s!&%;%_%J!
$B$*Ck$9$.$KCk?2$r$7$h$&$H;W$C$?$H$3$m!"(B
$BK?@h@8$+$i$NEEOC$NBP1~$J$I$GL2$l$:!#(B
$BCk2<$,$j$+$iK?%_!<%F%#%s%0$=$NB>!#ESCf!">/$75oL2$j$7$F$7$^$&!#(B
$B$$$+$s!#(B
$BM
$B$^$?%W!<%k$K9T$-$=$S$l$F$7$^$C$?!#L@F|$3$=$O!#(B
$B$h$/?2$k!#:#F|$bCO2
$BK;$7$$$;$$$+!"?4$,MnCe$+$J$$!#?<8F5[$7$F?5=E$K9TF0$9$k$h$&$K$7$h$&!#(B
$B8aA0Cf$OK?JY6/2q!#MhG/EY$+$i$O;J2q$=$NB>$r$d$k$3$H$K$J$j$=$&$@!#(B
$B$*Ck$K!"K?K]Lu$NFI=q0FFb$r0lDL$j40@.$5$;!"K?=PHG
$B$*Ck$OK\;0$NK?=j$G%+%l!The Philosopher's Magazine$B$N(B
$B:G?79f$r>/$7FI$`!#(BComplete Work of
Charles Darwin Online$B$H$$$&%@!<%&%#%s$NBg5,LO$J%*%s%i%$%s!&%"!<%+%$%V$,(B
$B$G$-$?$=$&$@!#$^$?!"%*%C%/%9%U%)!<%I$KF0J*NQM}8&5f=j(B
(The Oxford Centre for Animal Ethics)$B$,$G$-$?$=$&$@!#(B
Journal of Animal Ethics$B$r$^$b$J$/4)9T$9$k$H$N$3$H!#(B
$B=iBe=jD9$O(BAndrew Linzey$B$H$$$&65
$BM
$B$"$s$^$j?4G[$9$k$3$H$O$J$$$O$:$J$N$@$,!"2?$+?4$,Mn$ACe$+$J$$!#(B
$B$3$N$H$3$mK;$7$+$C$?$;$$$@$m$&$+!#$"$k$$$O!"=q@RIt$K9T$C$?$;$$$+!#(B
$B$O$?$^$?!">-Mh$KBP$9$kGyA3$H$7$?IT0B$+!#(B
$BGn;N9f$b
$BLk!"$R$5$7$V$j$K%W!<%k$X!#(B
$BA02s%W!<%k$K9T$C$?$N$O(B$B@h7n$N(B17$BF|(B$B$@$C$?$N$G!"(B
3$B=54V$V$j$@$C$?$h$&$@!#:#8e$O$b$C$HIQHK$K9T$/$h$&$K$7$h$&!#(B
30$BJ,$G$f$C$/$j(B1100M$B$[$I!#(B
$B$=$l$+$i5"Bp$7$FM)!#$f$C$/$j?)$Y$k!#>FCq$b>/$7!#(B
$B%a%b!#HnNA$r==J,$K$d$i$J$$$H0i$?$J$$?"J*!#(B
$BKLIw$K?a$+$l$F=i$a$F2j$r$D$1$kLZ!#(B
$B?e$r$d$j$9$.$F8O$l$k2V!#(B
$BFbH/@-$H30H/@-!#(B
$BN)GI$K0i$F$k$N$O$+$/$bFq$7$$!#(B
$B?7J9$rFI$s$G$+$iIwO$!#$R$5$7$V$j$K?tFH$r2r$3$&$H;W$C$?$i(B
$BFq$7$/$F;u$,N)$?$J$+$C$?!#(B
$B>/$7?2ITB-5$L#$@$,!"$J$s$H$+5/$-$k!#(B
$B8aA0Cf$OK?:J$H=UF|$K9T$-!"0aI~$NGcJ*$J$I!#$*Ck$+$iBg3X$K9T$-!"(B
$BK?%i%s%A%g%s%;%_%J!
$BCk2<$,$j$+$i!"K?B4O@@8$NH/I=$N=`Hw$r
$BIwO$!#(B
$B%a%b!#!V0lK\$NLZ$+$i!"@iK\$N%^%C%A$,$G$-$k!#(B
$B0lK\$N%^%C%A$G!"@iK\$NLZ$,G3$($k!W(B
(Stereophonics, `A Thousand Trees', $BK?:JLu(B)$B!#(B
$B%a%b!#;Y=P$,<}F~$r>e2s$l$P@V;z$K$J$j!"(B
$B@]
$BD+!"%4%_$r=P$7$F$+$iFsEY?2!#(B
$B$R$5$7$V$j$KJ?F|$K$f$C$/$j5/$-$F$7$^$&!#(B
$B$7$+$7!"$*$+$2$G@:?@E*$KM>M5$,La$C$F$-$?!#(B
$BMn$ACe$$$F$$$m$$$m9M$($k$3$H$K$7$h$&!#(B
$B$*Ck!"K?;a$H%i!<%a%s!#(B
$B$*Ck$9$.$+$iCk2<$,$j$^$G!"(B
$BK?B4O@@8$?$A$N%Q%o!<%]%$%s%H%U%!%$%k:n@.$N
$B>.1+$,9_$kCf!"5"Bp!#2H$G%[%C%H%o%$%s!#(B
$BK?Hs>o6P$N:NE@:n6H!#(B
$B$"$l!":#2s$O4JC1$9$.$?$h$&$@!#(B
$BMhG/$O$b$C$HFq$7$/$7$h$&!#(B
$BD+!"@8%4%_$r=P$7$F$+$iFsEY?2!#5/$-$F$+$i5^$$$G;EEY!#(B
$BK?:J$H0l=o$KAv$C$F1X$K9T$-!"CO2
$B2H$GM)!#%S!<%k!#(B
$B5nG/Gc$C$?%X%C%I%U%)%s(B(MX500)$B$O$^$@;H$($F$$$k!#(B
$B7A$O$"$l$@$,!"2;$O$=$l$J$j$J$N$G=EJu$7$F$$$k!#(B
$B%5!<%Y%$O@J8$K$D$$$F(B$B%a%b=q$-$,$"$k$,!"(B
$BB!4oDs6!@)EY$K$D$$$F=q$$$?$"$H!"(B
$B8x=01R@8NQM}3X$d(BDDR(Dead Donor Rule)$B$K$D$$$F$bF1$8J}K!O@$G$d$C$F$_$?!#(B
$B%5!<%Y%$O@J8;0It:n$H8@$($k(B($B$$$m$$$m$"$C$F$I$l$b$^$@@5<0$K$O(B
$B8xI=$5$l$F$$$J$$$o$1$@$,(B)$B!#(B
$B$^$@=,:n$N0h$r=P$J$$$,!"$@$$$VJ}K!O@$O3NN)$5$l$F$-$?!#(B
$B$-$A$s$H@h9T8&5f$r2!$5$($F!"$7$C$+$j$7$?8&5f$r$9$k$3$H$K$7$h$&!#(B
$B7k:'<0$GO/FI$5$l$k@;=q$N2U=j$K$D$$$F$7$P$i$/8!F$$9$k!#(B
$B%G%U%)%k%H$O%3%j%s%H?M$X$N
$BAa5/$-!#D+?)!#(B
$B:#G/$O3NDj?=9p$r$9$k$3$H!#(B3$B7n(B15$BF|$^$G!#(B
[$BK?Bg3X$NG_$NLZ(B]
$B8aA0Cf!"K?:J$H0l=o$KEE
$BCk2<$,$j!"EE
$BM
[$B%X%k(B?]
$B$D$$$G$K!":rF|!"ErEgE7?@$G;#$C$?
$BD+CY$/$^$G?2$F!"$5$-$[$I5/$-$k!#(B
$B:rHU$O$$$S$-$,$&$k$5$+$C$?$i$7$/!"(B
$BL@$1J}$KK?:J$KCm0U$5$l$k!#$$$+$s!#(B
$BL@F|$+$i$OB)$r;_$a$F?2$k$3$H$K$7$h$&!#(B
$B:#F|$OK?9;@5$r$d$i$J$1$l$P!#(B
$B$=$m$=$m8E$$;E;v$OJRIU$1$F!"?7$7$$8&5f$r;O$a$k$3$H!#(B
$B$=$&$$$($P:G6a!"5$$N8~$/$^$^$KK\$rFI$_5y$k$H$$$&$3$H$r$7$F$$$J$$!#(B
$B6HL3O"Mm!#:#G/$b(B$BK?@8L?!&0eNENQM}3XF~Lg%3!<%9(B$B$NJg=8$,;O$^$j$^$7$?!#(B
$BKh=5LZMKF|$NLk$K;22C$9$k5$$N$"$kJ}$O!"$U$k$C$F$41~Jg$/$@$5$$!#(B
$B$*Ck$9$.$^$GK?%H%^%H%=!<%9$r:n$k:n6H!#(B
$BCk2<$,$j$K<+E>
$B:rLk!"?<
$B@hF|!"!V$+$d$/$4$O$s!W$H$$$&$N$O2?$@$H$$$&OC$K$J$C$?$N$G!"(B
$B@h$[$I$h$&$d$/D4$Y$F8+$k$H!"$J$k$[$I!"$3$N8@MU$O
$B$+$d$/!Z2CLt![(B
(1)$B4AJ}$G!"
$B4XEl$G$O!V?f$-$3$_$4$O$s!W$H$$$&$h$&$@!#(B
$BD+!"Dj;~=P6P!#B4O@$NH/I=?3::2q$,$"$C$?$N$G!"B4O@@8$?$A$NH/I=$rJ9$/!#(B
$B$*Ck$O5W$7$V$j$KK?3$A/P'20$G!#$D$$$G$KK?K]Lu$N9;@5$N0lIt$rM9Aw!#(B
$B$*Ck$9$.$K$bK??3::2q$K=P@J$7!"$&$D$i$&$D$i$7$J$,$iH/I=$rJ9$/!#(B
$BCk2<$,$j$+$iK?%_!<%F%#%s%0!#K?;a$NH/I=$bJ9$/!#(B
$B:#F|$O?M$N%W%l%<%s$rJ9$$$F$P$+$j$@$J!#(B
$BM
$B$J$s$H$+5/$-$k!#?2ITB-5$L#!#>.1+!#(B
$BDj;~=P6P!#8aA0Cf$OK?B4O@?3::2q$K=P@J!#(B
$B1o$N2<$N%^%$%/;}$A$rL3$a$k!#(B
$B$*Ck$O8&5f<<$G!#(B
$B$=$&$$$($P!"F|7PJ?6Q3t2A$,9b$$$N$G!"(B
$BEj;q?.Bw$r>/$72rLs$7$F$*$$$?!#(B
$B%a%b!#$J$
$BCk2<$,$j!"K?BQ?L9);v$N@bL@2q$rJ9$-$K9T$/!#(B
$BH>J,?2$F$$$?$,!"$J$+$J$+@9$j>e$,$C$F$$$?$h$&$@!#(B
$B0z1[$9$N$OBgJQ$J$N$G!"$J$k$Y$/$J$i0z1[$7$?$/$J$$$,!"(B
$BBgCO?L$,5/$-$?$i:$$k$7$J$"!#(B
$BM
$BM
$BLk!"%W!<%k$G1K$0!#(B1100M$B!#(B
$B$J$s$+$^$?6;$K6ZFy$,IU$$$F$-$?!#(B
$B=5FsF|1K$0$h$&$K$7$h$&!#(B
$B1+$NCf!"<+E>
$B:#D+$b$J$s$H$+5/$-$k!#0l:rF|%+%-%U%i%$$rFs8D?)$Y$?$;$$$+!"(B
$B:rF|%A%g%3%l!<%H$r?)$Y$?$;$$$+!"6@$r8+$k$H4i$K%K%-%S$,!D!#(B
$B8aA0Cf$OK\;0$NK?%9%?%P$G?7J9$J$I!#$*Ck$OK?%i%s%A%g%s!&%;%_%J!<$G(B
$BK?%F%-%9%H$N2r@b$K%3%a%s%H$r$$$?$@$/!#46
$B%"%^%>%s$+$i!"(BJonathan Wolff$B$N(BAn Introduction to Political
Philosophy$B$N?7HG$=$NB>$,FO$$$F$$$?!#(BWolff$B$NK\$OJ88%0FFb$@$1$r(B
$B=q$-49$($?$h$&$G!"FbMF$O$[$H$s$IJQ$o$C$F$$$J$$$H$N$3$H!#(B
$BCk2<$,$j!"M9JX6I$G$$$m$$$mH/Aw$7$F$+$i!"$R$5$7$V$j$KAm9g?^=q4[$K9T$-!"(B
$B$H$3$m$G!"9;@5:n6H$r6lDK$K46$8$k$N$O$J$<$+(B
($B$?$$$F$$$OFI$^$:$KAw$jJV$7$F$7$^$&$N$O$J$<$+(B)$B!#(B
$B2a5n$N<+J,$NJ8>O$d
$BM
$BM)$r?)$Y$F$+$iHf3SE*$f$C$/$j2a$4$9!#IwO$!#(B
$B>/$7?2K7$9$k!#L2$$!#(B
$BD+F|?7J9Bh0lLL$K!"5_5^0e3X2q$,1dL?<#NECf;_$N;X?K0F8xI=$N5-;v!#(B
$B8aA0Cf$OK?%9%?%P$G?7J9!#$*CkA0$KBg3X$KMh$k$H!"(B
$B!XAOJ8!Y(B1-2$B7n9f$,(B50$BItFO$$$F$$$?!#(B
$B!V8yMx
$B?2ITB-5$L#$J$N$+!"?);v$KMH$2J*$,B3$$$?$N$+!"(B
$B?a$-=P$b$N$,L\N)$D!#(B
$B?4M}E*>cJI$r>h$j1[$($FK?9;@5$r$d$i$M$P!#(B
$B%a%b!#$$$m$$$m<9Ce?4$,$"$k$+$i?4$,F0MI$9$k!#$?$H$($PL>M@M_!#(B
$B?M$K;E$(I=$K=P$J$$9u;R$KE0$9$k7h?4$5$($"$l$P!"$o$:$i$o$5$l$:$K:Q$`!#(B
$B=P@$M_$b$7$+$j!#!V$=$l$i$NM_5a$O?M4VK\@-$KH4$-$,$?$/$"$k$b$N$G!"(B
$B9M$($F$I$&$J$k$b$N$G$O$J$$$N$G$O$J$$$G$9$+!W!#;n$7$F$_$l$P$h$$!#(B
$B2?;v$K$b0l0L$K$J$m$&$H$9$k$N$G$O$J$/!"Fs0L$+;00L$rL\;X$9$H$$$&(B
$B7h?4$@$1$G$b!"$:$$$V$s$H3Z$K$J$k$3$H$,$G$-$k$@$m$&!#(B
$B!V$^$@$=$3$^$GC#4Q$G$-$^$;$s!W!#(B
Have you never been mellow...?
$BLk$^$G8&5f<<$GK?9;@5:n6H!#A4A3?J$^$:!#$d$P$$!#(B
$BF(HrE*$K?tFH$r0lLd2r$/!#(B
$B%W!<%k$K9T$/$D$b$j$@$C$?$,!"2q0w>Z$r<+Bp$K$"$k%3!<%H$NCf$KK:$l$F$-$?$N$G!"(B
$B$=$N$^$^5"Bp!#(B
$BLkCf!"M)$r?)$Y$?$"$H!"K?:J$HAc3{$NL!2h5JCc$X!#(B
$BF,$,>/$7%j%;%C%H$5$l$?!#L@F|$b9;@5:n6H$r$;$M$P!#(B
$BL2$$$,$J$s$H$+5/$-$F%4%_=P$7!#(B
$B@8L?NQM}3X2q$G$$$D$b$40l=o$9$kK?;a$HK?;a$+$i!"7k:'$7$^$7$?$H$N%a!<%k!#(B
$B$a$G$?$$!#5$$N$;$$$+!"<+J,$N$H$3$m$r4^$a!"(B
$BF16H
$BK?:J$OD+$+$iBg3X$K9T$C$?$N$G!"(B
$B$*Ck$^$G?7J9$J$I$rFI$s$G$f$C$/$j!#(B
$B$*Ck$9$.!"$A$g$C$HJRIU$1$b$N!#(B
$BLs(B10$BG/A0$NKhF|?7J9$N@Z$jH4$-$,=P$F$-$?$j!#(B
$B8aA0Cf$+$iCmJ8$7$F$$$?%-%C%A%s$N%$%9$,FO$/$N$rBT$C$F$$$?$N$@$,!"(B
$BCk2<$,$j$K0lEYMh$?$N$rJ9$-F($7$?$h$&$G!":FG[C#$NEEOC$r$+$1$F(B
$BM
$BLk!">/$79;@5$r$9$k!#=*$o$i$s!#$"$H(B5$B>O$b;D$C$F$$$k!D!#$7$+$7!"(B
$B$3$l$,:G8e$N;E;v$K$J$C$F$bCQ$:$+$7$/$J$$$h$&$K!"(B
$B2hN5E@bM$rBU$i$J$$$h$&$K$7$J$1$l$P!#(B
$B$=$&$$$($P!"K?:J$K!VD+?)$r?)$Y$k!W$O>v6g$K$J$C$F$$$F$*$+$7$$$H;XE&$5$l$?!#(B
$B@5$7$/$O!VD+$4$O$s$r?)$Y$k!W$+!VD+?)$r$H$k!W$@$=$&$@!#(B
$B5nG/!"@VLgA0$K%J%A%e%i%k!&%m!<%=%s$,$G$-$?$3$H$r=q$$$F$$$k$,!"(B
$BN62,Lg$N$H$3$m$K$b%J%A%e%i%k!&%m!<%=%s$,$G$-!"Bg3XIB1!$NCf$d(B
$B0BED9VF2$N2<$K$b%m!<%=%s$,$G$-$?!#%m!<%=%s2=$9$kBg3X!#$H$$$&$+!"(B
$B$&$A$N7zJ*$NCf$K$b$G$-$F$/$l$s$+$J!D!#(B
$B$R$5$7$V$j$K$*Ck$4$m$^$G?2$F!"$f$C$/$jCk?)$r?)$Y!"?7J9$rFI$`!#(B
$B:rHU$O1+$,$1$C$3$&9_$C$F$$$?$h$&$@$,!"$=$N1+$b$*Ck$4$m$K$O;_$s$G!"(B
$B:#$O@2$l$F$$$k$h$&$@!#>/$7;6Jb$G$b$7$h$&$+!#(B
$BCk2<$,$j!";6Jb$K9T$3$&$H;W$C$F=P$+$1$?$i!"(B
$B%"%j$5$s$KM
$BM
$BK?:J$HM)!#$=$N8e!"$^$?9;@5:n6H!#
$BK?9;@5:n6H!"IwO$!"K?9;@5:n6H!#:#F|$O(B2$B>OJ,?J$s$@!#$"$H(B3$B>O$HJ88%0FFb!#(B
$B$,$s$P$l!#(B
$B%a%b!#FH?H$N$H$-$O=5Kv$[$H$s$I?M$H$7$c$Y$i$J$$$3$H$b$"$C$?$,!"(B
$B7k:'$7$F$+$i$=$&$$$&$3$H$O$J$/$J$C$?!#(B
$B5^B.$K
$B$$$D$bDL$jAa5/$-!#D+?)!"@vBuJ*43$7!"%H%$%lA]=|$J$I!#(B
$B3,CJ$+$iMn$A$?K?:J$NL5;v$r3NG'$7$?$"$H!"2H$r=P$k!#(B
$B$3$J$$$@$OIwO$>l$G3j$C$FE>$s$G$$$?!#O78e$,$H$F$b?4G[$@!#(B
$BK?%9%?%P$K4s$C$F?7J9$rFI$s$G$+$iBg3X$X!#9;@5$N;E;v$r$;$M$P!#(B
$B;(MQ$r$7$D$DCk2<$,$j$^$GK?9;@5!#(B
$BCk2<$,$j$KK?1!@8$,AjCL$KMh$?$N$G!"ErEgE7?@$^$G;6Jb$r$7$J$,$iOC$9!#(B
$BM
$B?
$BAa5/$-!#D+!"Bg3X$K9T$/A0$K:#F|$NH/I=$N=`Hw!#(B
$B:rHU<+E>
$B$$$m$$$m%a!<%k$d$iEEOC$d$i!#(B
$B$G$-$J$$;E;v$O0z$-$BLkCf(B
$BCk2<$,$j$+$iK?%_!<%F%#%s%0!#(B
$BESCf$G5oL2$j$r$7$F$$$?$3$H$r8e$GJ#?t$NF1N=$+$i;XE&$5$l$k!#(B
$B$9$_$^$;$s!#(B
$BM
$BK?9;@5!"IwO$!"K?9;@5!#$h$&$d$/Bh(B9$B>O$^$G=*$o$C$?!#(B
$B$"$H$OCm$dJ88%0FFb$J$I!#?2$J$$$H;`$K$=$&$J$N$G!"(B
$BL@F|5/$-$F$+$i$d$m$&!#(B
$B:#F|$OBgJQ%9%H%l%9%U%k$J0lF|$@$C$?!#(B
$B%W!<%k$G1K$$$G$$$J$1$l$P!"0_$K7j$,6u$$$F$$$?$+$b$7$l$J$$!#(B
$B4JC1$K?4$rF0$+$5$l$J$$$h$&!"CC$($J$1$l$P!#(B
$BIw
$B$$$D$bDL$jAa5/$-!#(B
$BD+?)$N$"$H!"D+$+$iK?9;@5$NB3$-$r$d$j!"$J$s$H$+40@.$9$k!#(B
$B40@.$9$k>/$7A0$K!"6a=j$K1[$7$F$-$?K?;a$,<+Bp$K$d$C$F$/$k!#(B
$B$*4j$$$7$F$$$?;E;v$N$?$a$K9;@5869F$rMB$+$C$F$/$l$k!#46
$B$=$l$+$iK?:J$N<+E>
$B8aA0Cf$OK?JY6/2q$K=P@J!#$=$N$"$HK?%F%-%9%H$NAjCL!#(B
$B$*Ck$O0lC65"Bp$7$F!"K?:J$H@i@P$NK?Cf2ZNAM}20$G!#$=$l$J$j!#(B
$B$*Ck$9$.$KBg3X$KLa$C$F$-$F!";(MQ!#(B
$B9;@5$,$R$H$^$:=*$o$C$F8*$N2Y$,9_$j$?$N$G!"(B
$B$7$P$7J|?4$9$k!#(B
$BM
$BLZB<7r<#$[$+Lu!X%m!<%^4n7`=8(B5$B!Y!J@>MN8EE5AQ=q!"5~ETBg3X3X=Q=PHG2q!"(B2002$BG/(B)
$B$@$H!"!V?M4V$N$9$k$3$H$O2?$R$H$D;d$K$H$C$FB>?M;v$H$O;W$o$J$$!W!#(B
$B$=$N$"$H!"K?2q5D$KBeM}=P@J!#:#2s$O9M$(;v$r$7$F$$$?$N$G(B($BFb?&$H$b8@$&(B)$B!"(B
$B5oL2$j$;$:!#(B
$B5"Bp$9$kA0$K!"=q@RIt$H9XGcIt$G$$$m$$$mGcJ*!#=q@RIt$G$O%_%k<+M3O@$N?7Lu!"(B
$BCf8x?7=q$N!X0BED9VF2(B1968-1969$B!Y!"c7F#9'!X?M$r(B10$BJ,$R$-$D$1$kOC$9NO!Y$r(B
$BGc$C$F$_$?!#(B
$B>FCq$r0{$_$J$,$iK?:J$H$f$C$/$jM<$4$O$s$r?)$Y$?$"$H!":rF|$N?7J9$rFI$s$@$j!"(B
$B%W%j%s%?%I%i%$%P$N%$%s%9%H!<%k$r
$BIwO$!#(B
$BHdO*1c$N$+$o$j$K$d$k4JC1$J%F%#!<%Q!<%F%#!<$G$+$1$k2;3Z$K$D$$$FK?:J$HAjCL!#(B
$B!V%\%X%_%"%s!&%i%W%=%G%#!W$r%k!<%W$G$+$1B3$1$?$i$I$&$+!"$J$I!#(B
$B$$$D$bDL$j$N;~4V$K5/$-$k!#(B
$BD+!"K?;a$,K?9;@5869F$r
$B%a%b!#BP?MO@K!!#!V$"$N?M$O%m%/$G$J$7$G$"$k!#(B
$B$7$?$,$C$F!"$"$N?M$N5DO@$OJ9$/$KCM$7$J$$!W!#(B
$BBP?MO@K!$O8"0R$KAJ$($k5DO@$NN"JV$7$G$b$"$k!#(B
$B!V$"$N?M$ON)GI$J?M$G$"$k!#$7$?$,$C$F!"$"$N?M$N5DO@$OJ9$/$KCM$9$k!W!#(B
$B$J$k$[$I!"$"$k
$BD+!"$D$$FsEY?2$7$F$7$^$&!#8aA0Cf$K=UF|$N<+E>
$BM
$B$=$l$+$iK?;a$i(B3$B?M$r<+Bp$K>7$-!"
$B:rHU$OFsF|J,$N?7J9$rFI$s$G$$$?$i?2$k$N$,CY$/$J$C$F$7$^$&!#(B
$BD+5/$-$k$H1+!#%4%_=P$7$r$7$?$"$H!"$D$$I[CD$KLa$C$F$7$^$$!"(B
$B$*CkA0$^$G5/$-$i$l$:!#(B
$B$=$m$=$m5/$-$h$&$+$H;W$C$F$$$?$H$3$m!"EEOC!#(B
$B=P$k$H!"K?=PHG
$B:rF|$+$iK?:J$,(B
$B$*Ck$9$.$+$iK?9;@5:n6H!#Ck2<$,$j$K=*$o$C$?$N$GH/Aw!#(B
$BK?=PHG
$BK]Lu$O$`$3$&(B10$BG/$O
$BM
$B8&5f<<$KLa$C$F$7$P$i$/;(MQ!#L@F|%W!<%k$K9T$/$3$H$K$7$F5"Bp!#(B
$B?7$7$$<+E>
$BLkCf!"K?:J$H<+E>
$B:#F|$O>/$7$f$C$/$j$G$-$?!#>/$7?4$rMn$ACe$1$h$&!#(B
$B:rLk$O$^$?Lk99$7!#$*J"$,8:$C$?$N$G!"?2$kA0$K$*CcDR$r:n$C$F$b$i$&!#(B
$BD+!"%4%_=P$7$r$7$F$+$iFsEY?2!#$h$/?2$k!#(B
$B$*J"$ND4;R$,>/$70-$+$C$?$,!"?2$?$iD>$C$?$h$&$@!#0lHUCf6/Iw!#(B
$BD+!"M9JX%]%9%H$KK?;a$N?7Cx$,FO$$$F$$$?!#46
$B%*%l$b$,$s$P$i$s$H$J$"!#L\2<$N?M@8$NL\I8$OC1Cx$@$m$&$+!#JY6/$7$h$&!#(B
$BCk2<$,$j!"K?:J$H<+E>
$B9q:]$3$I$b?^=q4[Fb$N5JCcE9$G0lI~$7$?$"$H!"K?:J$HJL$l$FBg3X$K9T$-!"(B
$B%W!<%k!#(B30$BJ,$G(B1200M$B$[$I1K$0!#(B
$BM
$BLkCf!"K?:J$K
$B$h$/?2$F>/$7CY$a$K5/$-$k!#(B33$B:P$K$J$C$?!#CfG/!#(B
$BK?:J$+$i=UJ*$N%;!<%?!<$r$b$i$&!#46
$BLkCf!"$A$g$C$HIw
$B$*CkA0$KK?:J$H=P$+$1$k!#;0ED@~$N8f@.Lg$G9_$j!"(B
$BEl5~%?%o!<$r4V6a$K8+$J$,$i0\F0!"K?%[%F%k$N:G>e3,$N%l%9%H%i%s$X!#(B
$BCk4V$+$i9b$$%7%c%s%Q%s$r0{$_$J$,$i?);v!#%9%N%C%V5$J,$rK~5J!#(B
$BE90w$N8@F0$,HyL/$KJQ$G$*$b$7$m$+$C$?!#(B
$B$=$l$+$iJb$$$FF|$N=P;766$X9T$-!"?e>e%P%9$K>h$C$F6yED@n$rAL>e$7!"(B
$B@uAp$X!#(B$BK?8$0u$N3s20(B
($B5~ET$G8@$($P0l_7HAI[$N$h$&$J$H$3$m(B)$B$G%V%j!<%U%1!<%9%5%$%:$N3s$r(B
$B9XF~$7$F$7$^$&!#$$$+$s!":#7n$b@V;z$K$J$j$=$&$@!D!#(B
$B$7$P$i$/@uAp$r$&$m$&$m$7$F$+$i!"%P%9$G@i@P$KLa$C$F$/$k!#ESCf!"$h$/?2$k!#(B
$BLk!"M)8e!"7k:'<0EvF|$N?J9T$K$D$$$FK?:J$HFs?M$G;W9M
$BIwO$!#(B
$B8|O+>J$,(B$B!V?77?%$%s%U%k%(%s%6BP:v%,%$%I%i%$%s!J%U%'!<%:#40J9_!K!J0F!K!W$X$N0U8+Jg=8$K$D$$$F(B$B$H$$$&$N$r$d$C$F$$$k$h$&$@!#MW%A%'%C%/!#(B
$B5/$-$k!#$A$g$C$H?2ITB-5$L#!#D+?)!#(B
$B4($$$;$$$+!"$*J"$ND4;R$,0-$$!#Iw
$B:#F|$O8aA0Cf$+$iK?%Y%s%?%`8&5f2q!#(B
$B$*Ck!"K?=PHG
$B$=$l$+$i5"Bp!#?7J9$rFI$s$@$i?2$h$&!#(B
$B?7J9!"IwO$!#(B
$B%a%b!#:#2s$NK]Lu$G!"J8>O=$6H$,$^$@$^$@B-$j$J$$$3$H$,$o$+$C$?!#(B
$BC0G0$K9;@5$9$kG&BQ$bI,MW$@!#K}?4$7$F$$$J$$$G@:?J$7$h$&!#(B
$B$$$D$bDL$j$N;~4V$K5/$-$k!#(B
$BD+?)$N$"$H!":rF|FO$$$?JY6/MQ$N%$%9(B($B%5%s%o%5%W%i%$$N$b$N(B)$B$rFs$DAH$_N)$F$k!#(B
$B$=$3$G;~4V@Z$l$H$J$C$?$N$G!"5^$$$GBg3X$X!#4y$O5"$C$F$+$iAH$_N)$F$k$3$H!#(B
$B8aA0Cf$OK?1Q8lJ88%9VFI!#%O%j%9!#(B
$B$*Ck$OK?%i%s%A%g%s%;%_%J!
$B5nG/$O:#F|$+$i%U%i%s%9$K9T$C$?$h$&$@!#$$$$$J$"!"5nG/$N%*%l!#(B
$BCk2<$,$j$KK?%_!<%F%#%s%0!#$9$0$K=*$o$k!#(B
$B%a%b!#(Bgenetic fallacy$B$K$D$$$F$O(BAnthony Flew, How to Think Straight$B$r8+$h!#(B`if this evolved from that, then this must always be that or
at least it must always be really or essentially that' (p. 120).
$B$?$H$($P!"!VMxB>?4$O$b$H$b$HMx8J?4$+$i@8$8$?$b$N$G$"$k!#$=$l$f$(!"(B
$BMxB>?4$OMx8J?4$KB>$J$i$J$$!W$J$I!#(B
$BM
$BLk!"%W!<%k$G(B1.2$B%-%m$[$I!#(B
$B%-%C%/$rN}=,$7$F$$$k?M$,$d$?$i$HB.$/1K$0$N$G$S$C$/$j$7$?!#(B
$B$"$N6-CO$rL\;X$7$F$,$s$P$m$&!#%P%?%P%?%P%?!#(B
$B$=$l$+$i5"Bp!#K?:J$HM<$4$O$s$r?)$Y$?$"$H!"(B
$B:rF|FO$$$?4y$rFs3,$NJY6/It20$GAH$_N)$F$k!#(B
$BL5;v$KJY6/It20$K4y$d0X;R$,B7$C$F$=$l$i$7$/$J$k!#(B
$B$"$H$O%@%s%\!<%k$dI~$rJR$E$1$J$$$H$J!D!#(B
$B$7$P$i$/GX$b$?$l$N$"$k0X;R$K:B$C$F$/$D$m$.$J$,$i?7J9!#(B
$B$"$H!"1Q9q$NK?6d9T$+$i!VEEOC$r$7$F$3$$!W$H$$$&
$BIwO$!#(B
$BJ}!9$K%a!<%k!#0lF|$OC;$$!#(B
$B:#F|$b?2ITB-5$L#$@$,!"L\3P$a$O$h$+$C$?!#%W!<%k$N$;$$$+!#%4%_=P$7!#(B
$BBg3X$N6&:Q$+$i7k:'0l;~6b$,?6$j9~$^$l$F$$$?!#46$BCk2<$,$j(B
$BD+!"K?%9%?%P$GD+4)$rFI$s$G$+$iDj;~=P6P!#K?JY6/2q$K=P@J!#(B
$B$*Ck!"BQ?L9);v$N4V$N0z1[$7@h$K$J$k7zJ*$N2<8+$X!#!D!#!D!#(B
$B$b$7K\Ev$K0z1[$9$3$H$K$J$k$J$i!":#G/EY$OHa;4$J0lG/$K$J$j$=$&$@!#(B
$B$*J[Ev$r?)$Y$F$+$i>/$75oL2$j!#(B
$B%I%%%&%)!<%-%s$N%i%$%U%:!&%I%_%K%*%s$r%Q%i%Q%i!#(B
$BM
$BLkCf!"$7$P$i$/Fs3,$NJY6/It20$GJY6/!#2wE,!#%7%s%,!
$B$=$&$$$($P!":#D+!"6H
02/Feb/2007 (Friday/vendredi/Freitag)
$BD+(B
$BLk(B
03/Feb/2007 (Saturday/samedi/Sonnabend)
$B$*Ck$9$.(B
$BLkCf(B
$B??LkCf(B
04/Feb/2007 (Sunday/dimanche/Sonntag)
$BD+(B
$BCk2<$,$j(B
$B??LkCf(B
05/Feb/2007 (Monday/lundi/Montag)
$BD+(B
06/Feb/2007 (Tuesday/mardi/Dienstag)
$BD+(B
$B??LkCf(B
07/Feb/2007 (Wednesday/mercredi/Mittwoch)
$BD+(B
$BCk2<$,$j(B
$BLkCf(B
$B??LkCf(B
08/Feb/2007 (Thursday/jeudi/Donnerstag)
$BD+(B
$B??LkCf(B
09/Feb/2007 (Friday/vendredi/Freitag)
$BD+(B
$B??LkCf(B
$B??LkCf(B2
10/Feb/2007 (Saturday/samedi/Sonnabend)
$BLk(B
$B$H$+1"KE(B$B$r;}$?$J$1$l$P?M@8$D$^$s$J$$$h$J!#(B
$BBg5A$K?H$rEj$8$h$&!#$I$&$$$&Bg5A$+$OHkL)!#$H$$$&$+!"$^$@8!F$Cf!#(B
$BLk(B2
$BLkCf(B
11/Feb/2007 (Sunday/dimanche/Sonntag)
$BD+(B
$B??LkCf(B
12/Feb/2007 (Monday/lundi/Montag)
$BD+(B
$B??LkCf(B
13/Feb/2007 (Tuesday/mardi/Dienstag)
$BD+(B
$B??LkCf(B
14/Feb/2007 (Wednesday/mercredi/Mittwoch)
$BD+(B
$B$*Ck$9$.(B
$BLk(B
15/Feb/2007 (Thursday/jeudi/Donnerstag)
$BD+(B
$BLk(B
$B5$;}$A$h$/5oL2$j$9$k(B$B??LLL\$K9;@5:n6H$r$9$k!#(B
$BH]DjJ8$r9NDjJ8$H$7$FLu$7$F$$$k$H$3$m$rH/8+$7!"Nd4@$r$+$/!#(B
$B"*G'<1$r2~$a$k$Y$-$G$9!#8m;zC&;z$dJ8>O2~A1$NM>CO$OI,$:$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B"*8=:_$N<+J,$O2a5n$N<+J,$H$=$l$[$IJQ$o$C$F$$$J$$$3$H$rG'<1$9$Y$-$G$9!#(B
16/Feb/2007 (Friday/vendredi/Freitag)
$BD+(B
$BCk2<$,$j(B
$B??LkCf(B
17/Feb/2007 (Saturday/samedi/Sonnabend)
$BD+(B
18/Feb/2007 (Sunday/dimanche/Sonntag)
$BCk2<$,$j(B
$BLkCf(B
19/Feb/2007 (Monday/lundi/Montag)
$BD+(B
$B$*CkA0(B
$B??LkCf(B
$B??LkCf(B2
20/Feb/2007 (Tuesday/mardi/Dienstag)
$BCk2<$,$j(B
$BCk2<$,$j(B2
21/Feb/2007 (Wednesday/mercredi/Mittwoch)
$BD+(B
$B??LkCf(B
22/Feb/2007 (Thursday/jeudi/Donnerstag)
$BD+(B
$BM
23/Feb/2007 (Friday/vendredi/Freitag)
$B$*Ck(B
$B2H=P(B$B30=P$7$F$$$k$N$G!"(B
$B$*Ck$O6a$/$NJ[Ev20$NJ[Ev$r=82q<<$G?)$Y$k!#(B
$BLk(B
24/Feb/2007 (Saturday/samedi/Sonnabend)
$B$*CkA0(B
$B??LkCf(B
25/Feb/2007 (Sunday/dimanche/Sonntag)
$B$*CkA0(B
$B??LkCf(B
26/Feb/2007 (Monday/lundi/Montag)
$BD+(B
$B??LkCf(B2
27/Feb/2007 (Tuesday/mardi/Dienstag)
$BCk2<$,$j(B
$BM
$B??LkCf(B
$B??LkCf(B2
28/Feb/2007 (Wednesday/mercredi/Mittwoch)
$BD+(B
$BLkCf(B
$B??LkCf(B