欧州人権裁判所の判決
n第十四条 (差別の禁止)
–プリティ: 健常者は合法的に自殺できるが、彼女は他人の手を借りなければ死ねないのに、それが許されていない
–判決: 自殺幇助を認めることは濫用の可能性を開くので、この区別は正当化される
–
Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) - no violation.
Mrs Pretty said that the current law discrimated against her, as an able-bodied person would be legally able to commit suicide, whereas she could not without help.
The ruling stated: "There was, in the Court's view, objective and reasonable justification for not distinguishing in law between those who were and those who were not physically capable of committing suicide.
"Cogent reasons existed for not seeking to distinguish between those who were able and those who were unable to commit suicide unaided.
"The borderline between the two categories would often be a very fine one and to seek to build into the law an exemption for those judged to be incapable of committing suicide would seriously undermine the protection of life which the 1961 Act was intended to safeguard and greatly increase the risk of abuse."